Ask A Referee
< backSan Jose vs Dallas
A match between San Jose Earthquakes and FC Dallas on September 24, 2005 provides an
excellent example of the proper implementation of the current guidelines on offside. In the 68th
minute, with the score 1-0 in favor of FC Dallas, a series of three plays by San Jose began which
resulted in the tying goal. Attached are two clips of the situation, one from an overhead view
and one from a touchline perspective.
San Jose player #13 (Ricardo Clark) passed the ball from a point just above the Dallas penalty area. At that moment, San Jose player #24 (Wade Barrett) was clearly in an offside position on the left side of the penalty area while San Jose player #9 (Brian Mullan) was in an onside position on the right side. The ball was played forward and deflected by a Dallas defender Steve Jolley.
Both Barrett and Mullan began moving to the ball but it was obvious both from their respective distances to the ball and from the path of the ball itself that, despite the effort by Barrett, Mullan would clearly arrive at the ball first from his onside position. There was accordingly no offside offense by Barrett.
Subsequently, Mullan played the ball across the face of the goal and the ball was put into the net by San Jose player #25 (Brian Ching) who was behind the ball when it was played by Mullan. Again, there was no offside offense because Ching was onside when Mullan passed the ball laterally.
The referee and lead assistant referee were both in position to judge not only the contact by the Dallas defender but also the relative positions of Barrett and Mullan and to determine accurately that Barrett could neither interfere with the play nor with an opponent. As confirmed by these clips, both officials correctly interpreted the facts of play as well as the requirements of Law 11 and are commended for their decisions.
